Unsealed Amazon ad surcharges are now public in an FTC and 22-state case filed August 31, 2026. The complaint alleges a hidden soft reserve lifted prices up to 50% on ordinary days and up to 250% around Prime Day and Black Friday, plus an extra $87 million worldwide in the 2022 holidays. These are allegations, not findings: Amazon denies them and has not been held liable.
Updated November 8, 2026
Key Takeaways
- Complaint alleges ordinary markups of up to 50% and peak markups of up to 250%.
- Plaintiffs cite a 20% 2021 holiday CPC rise and $87 million in 2022.
- Amazon says no advertiser pays above its bid; the case is unproven.
- Audit peak CPC against bids before Black Friday 2026 spend locks.
Which Amazon ad surcharges are now public?
According to Sell Through’s lawsuit explainer, the suit is Case 2:26-cv-03097, an 181-page Western District of Washington complaint under Section 5(a) of the FTC Act, plus 22 state claims. The Commission voted 2-0. Surcharge rates were still redacted in that November 4 account.
PublishMyBlog dates the FTC announcement of the unsealed 50% and 250% figures to November 5. Court Cast, reporting on November 6, describes the allegations and does not date the update to November 5.
The complaint alleges that “after Amazon runs the auction, it secretly replaces the GSP auction price with a higher ‘soft reserve’ price.” It dates Sponsored Brands to late 2018, Sponsored Products to 2019, and display auctions by 2023. PublishMyBlog cites a footnote placing the first Sponsored Products search surcharges in July 2019.
The complaint says the practice touched about 1.2 million US advertisers, including more than 500,000 small and medium-size businesses, and alleges Amazon “likely illegally extracted over 20 billion dollars.” Court Cast says advertisers were not told a surcharge had been introduced.
How do alleged markups map to peak-day CPCs?
The complaint describes separate ceilings above the auction result, not a peak premium stacked on an ordinary-day markup: up to 50% on ordinary days, and up to 250% on Prime Day and Black Friday. Sell Through says compare 2025 event days with normal days before setting Black Friday 2026 bids. PublishMyBlog’s point is not to treat 2021–2023 event CPCs as a normal baseline.
| Allegation in the complaint | Figure | When |
|---|---|---|
| Price above the auction result | Up to 50% | Ordinary days |
| Price above the auction result | Up to 250% | Prime Day and Black Friday |
| Average cost per click | Up 20%; some advertisers more than 200% | 2021 holidays |
| Extra worldwide revenue | $87 million | 2022 holidays |
| One large food and beverage brand | Paid over 100% more | Prime Day 2023 |
| Revenue-gap target tied to reserves | $40 million | 2023 |
Sell Through says the complaint describes a 2024 Spain test: Amazon tested raising, for some advertisers, the share of clicks paid at the winner’s own bid from 48% to 80%. The FTC press release said increases on high-volume days were “far greater.”
What does Amazon say the soft reserve is?
Amazon’s August response, quoted by Sell Through, calls the suit “misguided” and states: “In no scenario does an advertiser pay more than their bid.” If a winning bid beats both reserves, “they pay the soft reserve”; if it does not, “they pay their bid.” PublishMyBlog says Amazon has not answered the unsealed details in public.
- From 2019 through 2024, average cost per click “remained flat when adjusted for inflation.”
- In 2024, “approximately 92% of selected Sponsored Products ads were not the highest bid.”
- Advertisers “saved over $8 billion from 2021 to 2025.”
- The average winning Sponsored Products bid fell 50% (2019–2024 in the body; 2019–2025 in the summary).
If cost per click sits near the bid, price the click from margin. Amazon closes with, “We look forward to making our case in court.”
What should buyers check before Black Friday?
The lawsuit does not change the auction on offer. Sell Through’s safer assumption is that the bid is the price, especially if cost per click sits near the bid. PublishMyBlog says not to pull budget off Amazon over unproven claims, and not to treat 2021–2023 peaks as a normal baseline.
Before spend locks, check the account:
- Divide 90-day Sponsored Products cost per click by bid. Near 1.0 means you paid about the bid.
- Rank the top 20 targets by spend. Reset from break-even: conversion rate times profit per order.
- Repeat for Sponsored Brands and Sponsored Display. Compare 2025 event days with ordinary days.
- In Cyber Week, pair cost per click with conversion rate so a price jump is not weak demand.
- Archive billing to mid-2019. The complaint says click-level auction results were not provided.
Court Cast says a manager blamed increased competition when an advertiser asked if the second-price auction had changed. PublishMyBlog adds that the manager denied a bug or style change, which the FTC calls misleading.
State requests include “the refund of monies paid,” but there is no ruling yet. As of November 6 reporting, Amazon has not been held liable. See also the FTC’s orders to Walmart and Target on personalized pricing.
Frequently asked questions
What is a soft reserve price on Amazon ads?
The complaint says it replaced the second-price result with a higher price after the auction. Amazon says winners pay that reserve or their bid, and never more than the bid.
Which Amazon ad products does the lawsuit name?
The complaint names Sponsored Products, Sponsored Brands, and Sponsored Display. It dates Sponsored Brands to late 2018, Sponsored Products to 2019, and display auctions by 2023.
Has a court ruled on the Amazon ad surcharge claims?
No. The case was filed August 31, 2026, and as of November 6 reporting Amazon had not been held liable.
Will Amazon advertisers get refunds from the case?
Not from any ruling yet. State requests include “the refund of monies paid,” but the litigation is still pending.