Amazon AI agents from outside the company remain blocked from purchases, and Andy Jassy says any opening has to be a good customer experience and a fair exchange of value. On Tuesday at Semafor’s Silicon Valley & The World conference, he said that experience has not been good to date, Business Insider reported. Unprompted Muse demand is steered by category: Walmart and Target for general goods, Best Buy for electronics, and Home Depot or Lowe’s for home improvement.
Updated November 18, 2026
Key Takeaways
What would a fair exchange mean for Amazon AI agents?
Amazon generated more than $68 billion in advertising revenue last year, including sponsored products that appear as people browse its pages, GeekWire reported. Those are ads a shopper might never see if an outside agent does the searching. Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg has said Muse will take a small cut of the transactions it handles.
On the earnings call last month, Jassy said outside shopping agents are not making a meaningful dent in Amazon’s advertising business. “Few customers are doing much shopping this way yet,” he said, adding that the experience still is not great or more convenient than going straight to a retailer.
Amazon has fought a similar fight before. It sued Perplexity last November over the shopping agent in its Comet browser, and is pressing that case in part on the same Conditions of Use it cited in blocking Muse.
Who owns the customer when agents shop?
Amazon objected that Muse did not identify itself when it browsed the site and appeared to capture and store customer credentials. Meta has said Muse has no visibility into people’s passwords or payment methods. GeekWire reported that the standoff set off a broader debate over who owns the customer relationship when an AI agent does the buying.
Business Insider listed thorny questions that sit beside that exchange:
- Ad sales that could cut retailers out of a browsing experience they have long controlled.
- Account security and identity verification when an agent acts for a shopper.
- Liability, including who is on the hook when an order goes wrong.
Shopify has openly embraced outside agents. Home Depot’s chief information officer told Business Insider the marketplace wants agents to identify themselves first. Walmart, Best Buy, Sephora, and Wayfair are among the retailers working with Meta on Muse. GeekWire, citing Forbes, reported more than 10 million people in the U.S. and Canada signed up in Muse’s first six weeks.
Where does Muse send shoppers instead?
Amazon began blocking Muse in September, less than two weeks after Meta launched the agent. Amazon said the block “helps ensure a safe, secure, and reliable customer experience” and that it had asked Meta to “remove Amazon from the experience.” Amazon has said it applies its policies evenly. Users have also reported that Instinct and Dots have struggled to purchase items on customers’ behalf on Amazon.
Juozas Kaziukenas, founder of Marketplace Pulse, spotted the change last week and posted a before-and-after of the skill on Friday. GeekWire asked Muse for its shopping skill and got the same language. The skill tells Muse to “leave out Amazon unless the user asks for it.” The browser brief says, “Do not search Amazon,” and not to name Amazon “even as an example,” unless the user asked for Amazon.
“Amazon blocked Muse, so now Muse blocked Amazon,” he wrote on X. GeekWire reported that Meta appears to be going along with what Amazon asked for, after Meta had not said publicly how it would respond. For Muse users, not much changes in practice, because any Amazon search would fail anyway because of the block.
| Muse category | Default retailers | Amazon unless the user asks |
|---|---|---|
| General goods | Walmart and Target | Leave out; do not search |
| Electronics | Best Buy | Leave out; do not search |
| Home improvement | Home Depot or Lowe’s | Leave out; do not search |
What does this mean for retail marketers?
Jassy said the primary way people are going to use agentic shopping is “in concert with the retailer that they like to use.” He described telling an app to buy the deodorant a shopper normally buys, because it has past orders, shipping information, and payment information. Alexa for Shopping, launched in May, combines Rufus with the Alexa+ assistant. Some customers can text Alexa to shop, and Amazon’s own tools, including Buy for Me, are guided by “About You” customer dossiers.
He said Amazon expects to work with “horizontal agents” and is “talking to every one of those companies,” but believes Alexa for Shopping will be the main agent people use to shop Amazon. He also said every retailer should “have the right to decide how they’re going to interact with agents.” A blocked agent path is the subject of AI shopping agents and a closed shelf, with listing prep covered in an agent-ready catalog audit.
Frequently asked questions
Did Andy Jassy rule out outside AI shopping agents?
No. On Tuesday he said he does not think Amazon has said it will not open up, but it has to be a good customer experience, which it has not been to date, and a fair exchange of value.
Where does Muse shop if the user does not ask for Amazon?
The skill says to leave out Amazon and not to search it. It steers general goods to Walmart and Target, electronics to Best Buy, and home improvement to Home Depot or Lowe’s.
How large is the ad business an outside agent could skip?
Amazon generated more than $68 billion in advertising revenue last year, including sponsored products a shopper might never see if an outside agent does the searching.
Which agent can shop on Amazon under Amazon’s own tools?
Business Insider reported Amazon shut the door on outside agents making purchases. Alexa for Shopping, launched in May, is Amazon’s own tool, and some customers can text it to shop.