Nearly 1 in 3 Amazon deal prices advertised for Black Friday and Cyber Monday were not lower than the prior month, Groundwork Collaborative reported on November 16, 2026. Of more than 350 products Amazon promoted as deals, 29.1% were the same price or higher than in the preceding 30 days, and 9.4% cost more. Read as a reference-price test, that is the bar for deal depth, MAP, and a struck-through was price before the next badge.
Updated November 16, 2026
Key Takeaways
- 29.1% of reviewed Amazon deals were not cheaper than the prior 30 days.
- 9.4% of promoted deals cost more than in the previous month.
- A 90-day lookback put the same-or-higher share at nearly 60%.
- Half of same-or-higher items were at or below the deal price on at least eight days.
What did the Amazon deal prices test measure?
Groundwork asked whether holiday deals were cheaper than prices in the preceding weeks, and often found they were not. The sample was products Amazon advertised as deals. On its Black Friday 2025 deals page, Amazon said, “With so many deals to explore, we’ve handpicked some of the best ones you’ll find.”
Shoppers see a struck-through list price or typical price, an event price, a red percent-off badge, and a “Black Friday Deal” label. The review did not grade that badge. It compared the event price with recent prices. Among the 29.1% that were not cheaper than the prior month, half had already been priced at or below the deal price on at least eight of the 30 days before the sale.
How do 30-day and 90-day lookbacks compare?
On these figures, a longer window makes a lowest-price claim harder to defend. The same-or-higher share rises to nearly 60% over 90 days. The higher-price share nearly triples, from 9.4% to 27%.
| Lookback before the sale | Same price or higher | Higher price |
|---|---|---|
| 30 days | 29.1% | 9.4% |
| 90 days | Nearly 60% | 27% |
Groundwork reported that in November 2025, Doug Herrington, CEO of Worldwide Amazon Stores, said Amazon was “providing customers with incredible Black Friday Week and Cyber Monday deals” with “deep discounts across more than 35 categories and some of our lowest prices of the year so far on top brands.” Setting that promise beside a 90-day window in which 27% of promoted deals were higher than an earlier price is analysis, not a line in the report.
What should teams change in deal depth, MAP, and was prices?
It is not a published Amazon policy change. The test’s reference was the recent price, not the list price behind the badge. Brands can still use that method on their own deal files.
- Set deal depth against the trailing 30-day price. A cut from list can still fall inside the 29.1%.
- A MAP floor at the event price is not a discount if the item was already priced at or below that level on eight or more of the prior 30 days.
- The page’s was price is list or typical price. A history check uses the earlier price.
- Handpicked placement is not proof of savings. That is where this review looked.
Expect a repeat. Amazon runs at least four major sale events a year. It added Prime Big Deal Days in October 2022 and the Big Spring Sale in 2024, and it ran a 12-day Black Friday Week in 2025.
Why does a flat badge still pull spend?
Shoppers are already planning around the label. Groundwork reported that 70% of U.S. customers plan to take advantage of the Black Friday and Cyber Monday promotional period, up from 64% in 2025. In 2025, major sale events drove nearly $70 billion in online spending, with Amazon at the center.
The report notes that Amazon’s e-commerce share is nearly 40%, that nearly one-third of its revenue falls in the fourth quarter, and that online Black Friday spending grew 9.1% in 2025, to nearly $12 billion.
Lindsay Owens, Groundwork’s president and CEO, wrote in an October 2026 CNBC piece that the same item can be priced differently by store, website, app, login state, and device. That is not this review. For sellers, one struck-through Amazon price is a thin was-price if another path is already lower. An event price that does not beat the prior 30 days is not a discount.
Frequently asked questions
What share of Amazon deals were not cheaper than the prior month?
Of more than 350 products Amazon advertised as deals, Groundwork Collaborative found 29.1% were the same price or higher than in the prior month, and 9.4% were priced higher.
How do the results change on a 90-day lookback?
The share priced the same or higher rises to nearly 60%, and the share priced higher rises to 27%, Groundwork reported.
Were these Amazon’s handpicked deals?
Groundwork reviewed products Amazon advertised as deals, including the Black Friday 2025 page where Amazon said it had handpicked some of the best.
How often had no-savings items already reached the deal price?
Half of the items priced the same or higher than the prior month had been at or below the deal price on at least eight of the 30 days before the sale.